If Machines Make Art, Is It Still Art?

wp-15895119815331073309784.png

A few days ago a fellow artist sent me a message on Instagram about a post he had saw that he thought I might be curious to see. In the message was a video clip of a person creating a drawing with an electric stippling pen. I don’t know if anyone has seen these pens (watch video below if you’re curious) but basically they’re an electric charged pen with a nib that rapidly goes up and down while releasing ink onto your drawing surface much in the same way you would use a regular pen in traditional stippling. It looks like a pretty cool, convenient and time saving art tool. But after watching the video, I was reminded of an MIT article that I read about teaching machines how to make art and I couldn’t help but wonder, exactly when and where do we draw the line between convenience and technology and express of the human spirit? As I thought about it more I couldn’t help but feel that the electric stippling pen was like cheating a bit artistically. To me, it’s akin to you grandma baking buttermilk biscuits from scratch compared to popping open a can of Pillsbury. Okay, maybe that’s comparing apples to oranges, anyways Pillsbury’s Grands are good as hell but I digress. At least with the electric pen, you’re still controlling the movement of the pen, so it’s not like it’s creating a drawing all by itself and you’re also still employing your own imagination to the artwork. But maybe it’s just me that’s haunted by this nagging, creepy feeling that gadgets and machines are taking over our lives and that in the process we’re losing something. What that something is, I can’t really put my finger on it but I’m sure two or three decades from now we’ll start to see reports and research papers coming out pinpointing what it is but it will be too late to correct the course.
Art has always been a form of human expression, so if we’re striving to teach machines how to be creative and make art, something that was once solely a human endeavor, can we still say that it’s art? When you take the humanness out of the equation of creativity is it still creativity or is it just an algorithm mimicking human creativity?
Needless to say, you won’t see me drawing with an electric stippling pen partly because I’m a traditionalist in that respect but also because stippling is my form of meditation that allows my mind and soul to slow down, which in this data driven, high tech, high speed, constantly connected, modern life we’re living, slowing down is something the human spirit sorely needs . And I don’t want some gadget taking that away from me.

Published by

Q.

Pen and ink artist inspired by Nature, Beauty, Spirit and Song.

4 thoughts on “If Machines Make Art, Is It Still Art?”

  1. I see this as another tool. As this artist says, it’s not like traditional stippling, it has a different look. It’s another tool. In the hands of an artist it has possibilities. I thought you were talking about the ones that are connected to a computer similar to a quilting machine. This may be a gadget, but it’s controlled by a human hand and mind.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think the speed of modern life has eaten away at our capacity to be patient and focused enough to put in the time to create. I feel this pressure myself at time. One of our popular mottos is: “Time is money.” So we make gadgets and tools of convenience. They may save time but I think the conveniences eat away at our creativity.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I agree! I live a very slow (by the world’s standards) life, making sure to spend time in nature, in quiet thought, and resting. This has led to a much more relaxed life and a more peaceful, contented frame of mind. To me, I think people would benefit from slowing down and putting their energies into what really matters…. and I think creating matters.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to Q. Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s